Gardening tips: use real soil not compost from the shop

74

By Bard of Ely

Growing potted plants

Many people enjoy growing potted plants and I am one of them. I have always love to see what I can get to root and to flower and fruit.

I have often been said to be "green-fingered" but that was mainly because of my success as a home gardener when I lived in Ely in Wales. Surprisingly, since I have lived in Tenerife, where there is a much better climate, my efforts at growing plants in pots and containers have gone decidedly downhill. However, recently I figured out why!

Potting soil photo

Chris Radcliff from San Diego, CA, USA. Color-corrected and cropped by Daniel Case 2008-07-10
See all 2 photos
Chris Radcliff from San Diego, CA, USA. Color-corrected and cropped by Daniel Case 2008-07-10

Pineapple photo

Pineapple in flower in a house in Cardiff
Pineapple in flower in a house in Cardiff

Problems with pests

Gardeners and farmers on Tenerife have terrible problems caused by insect pests. We have white fly, aphids, mealy bugs, red spider mite, caterpillars, scale insects and ants that transport the tiny insects they farm on to the plants you are trying your best to grow.

The answer many resort to is to use insecticides but I don't believe in that approach. The problem is all the non-harmful methods of pest control don't make much progress in stopping the invading armies of bugs.

But I have realised it isn't just the numbers of pests that are to blame because many of the plants grown in pots are simply not very strong specimens. I have had plants with yellow leaves, spindly stems, poor growth and rotting in the soil. 

Recently I was thinking about this and realised it was quite possibly due to the various potting composts I had been buying from shops here. You know the sort of stuff that comes in plastic bags in various sizes. Perhaps this was why my plants were not doing like I expected?

Now admittedly I have only got a balcony to grow my plants on but it gets plenty of sunshine and light. The strange thing is though that I have done much better on a windowsill of an unheated house in Cardiff in Wales.

In those conditions I twice grew pineapples and made the HTV Wales news headlines with my achievement. I naturally thought I could do better again in subtropical Tenerife but I was wrong and lost the pineapple plant I tried growing here.

A big difference apart from the location and temperature was the growing medium. In my house in Cardiff I grew all my plants in simple soil I got out of the back garden and just filled the pots up with the stuff. Any earthworms that were included I thought would be beneficial in their new potted homes just as they are in a garden. The soil is as it is in nature.

Contrasting this with what you get with a commercial potting compost today is a growing medium devoid of all life. It has been sterilised. There are definitely no worms to circulate it with their tunnels and move nutrients around. The compost that comes in a bag is dead.

My Cardiff pineapple

My solution

The solution I decided to try was to quit using the stuff from the shops and go back to using what comes out of the ground and is provided free of charge by Mother Nature. So when I go out for a walk in the neighbourhood I live in I take a trowel and a strong bag with me and collect some earth from any areas of waste ground I pass. 

Now admittedly this type of soil has the seeds of weeds in it but I simply pull them out as they germinate. But what a difference it has made to my plants that are all looking stronger and have dark green foliage like they should do now. So my advice, if you are having problems growing house-plants in pots and containers and have been using compost you bought from a shop or garden centre, is to try using some ordinary soil out of the garden. 

It makes good sense because it is full of natural minerals and plant nutrients and it's free!

Copyright © 2011 Steve Andrews. All Rights Reserved.

Comments

BobbiRant profile image

BobbiRant Level 4 Commenter 13 months ago

I have always worried about diseases in the outdoor soil when placed in pots, but maybe I'll go back to trying the garden soil as I love houseplants too and grow many. Useful info. Thanks.

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Where I live the insect pests arrive by air and by ant and I am more worried about losing my plants due to weakness than about diseases in the soil. So far my plants in natural earth are doing so much better and ones I have re-potted are reviving!

funride profile image

funride 13 months ago

Great Hub! There`s nothing like Nature... I have mixed some compound from shops on my garden but now I only add humus from my own compost pile. I also have some problems with insects and snails but I started growing mallows in the garden and sometimes I spray with watter having tobacco, and other plants like nettles... we still must keep all the vegs under attention so that the bugs don`t eat them all :D

That`s Nature doing her beautiful work ;)

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Thanks for posting, funride!

Harlan Colt profile image

Harlan Colt Level 3 Commenter 13 months ago

Bard,

This is a fabulous idea. Thank you very much, I am going to try just this very solution. Excellent!

- Harlan

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Good luck! Thanks for posting, Harlan!

Amanda Berry 13 months ago

Interesting article. I've used garden soil in the past, I suppose mainly because not having a car finding a garden centre within easy walking or cycling distance in Cardiff is not easy.

I don't know if it has worked better though I'm not very good with house plants. Well I suppose mainly because I forget to water them and they die. So I don't actually have any house plants at the moment. Although I do dometimes buy a tray of living lettuce and keep it going for a while whilst I eat it :)

The only thing I have found in the past which has put me off using Cardiff soil for food plants such e.g. Tomatoes is they don't seem to taste very nice. Well my former landlord planted some tomatoes at the last place I lived and I found they had a kind of earthy musty damp flavour which I didn't like. Wherase tomatoes grown in grow bags seem to have a much nicer sweeter flavour. So it seems some foods can get tainted with polluted soil.

I suppose it depends where you live really. The trouble with Cathays it's in the middle of a city and the ground must be full of pollution. Well I notice where I live the widowsils get covered with black soot when I leave the windows open in the warmer weather. Although fuel is unleaded these days I dare say there must still be tones of lead and other pollutants in the soil. So I wouldn't say the soil in Cathays is the most healthy for food crops. It rains soot. Actually it amazes me people worry about secondary smoking and don't seem to be bothered about the tones of carcenagenic black soot they are breathing in. Saying that I guess other parts of Cardiff might not be quite so bad as Cathays. :)

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

The air pollution you point out is what I am sure is the real reason for the illnesses attributed by chemtrail-believers to what are actually just contrails. Yes, the air is badly polluted in many places.

mistyhorizon2003 profile image

mistyhorizon2003 Level 7 Commenter 13 months ago

Great Hub Steve, I confess I do use a lot of compost in my containers, but this year have recycled much of last years spent compost by having dumped it in my compost bins along with normal household waste etc. This year it is full of worms, and I have mixed this with fresh compost in order to bulk it out. Some of my container shallots have also been grown in a combination of bagged topsoil soil and this odd mixed up compost. Another advantage to using real soil of course, is that it holds moisture better, so there is less watering to worry about.

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Hi Cindy! It has been really frustrating for me as I am sure you can imagine but I have had enough of the shop composts! I wish I had a proper garden! I also hate the plastic pots, not just because plastic is a real danger to the environment and marine life, but because they are not porous and don't breathe like the good old-fashioned clay pots!

dearabbysmom profile image

dearabbysmom 13 months ago

What a timely hub! I just picked up a bunch of starter plants and every year I wonder how they grow in that stuff. It feels like shredded insulation, and has no density to hold water. Flats that don't get planted right away are bone dry an hour after watering. So I think you are really on to something. Congratulations on that pineapple, too!

Peter Owen profile image

Peter Owen 13 months ago

Any thoughts on moles??

I'm overrun

mistyhorizon2003 profile image

mistyhorizon2003 Level 7 Commenter 13 months ago

Have you read my recent hub on how to make plant pots from newspaper Steve, it might help you solve the smaller plastic pot problem to a point?

What I don't like about clay pots is that they do dry out so very fast, and I reckon in Tenerife you would find you were having to water several times a day just to stop them drying up.

mistyhorizon2003 profile image

mistyhorizon2003 Level 7 Commenter 13 months ago

suggestion on the moles, use childrens plastic windmills inserted into the mole hills, the vibrations of the 'sails' turning upsets the moles and they move away. Another option is to put moth balls down the holes, as the smell annoys them.

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Thanks for your comments, dearabbysmom, Peter and Cindy!

Peter, I happen to like moles and there are none on this island. Good points, Cindy, I will have a look later on but I would still prefer clay I think!

GusTheRedneck profile image

GusTheRedneck Level 6 Commenter 13 months ago

Hi Steve - There is dirt and there is "dirt." Good garden soil (or potting soil) is a mix of mineral "dirt" and composted organic stuff. Around here we have mostly clay (mineral) stuff, and it gets hard and loses moisture really fast. From a good hub by lmmartin I learned about fertilizing with diluted sea water. Worked very nicely and helped to bolster our not-so-good dirt so that plants enjoyed their homes in it.

Gus :-)))

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Thanks for your feedback, Gus! The soil here is volcanic and very fertile though like yours dries out fast but it is so much better than the stuff in a plastic bag!

The Jet profile image

The Jet 13 months ago

Thanks a lot for your help.

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

I am glad you found this hub of interest!

teresa8go profile image

teresa8go 13 months ago

Not only is earth "full of natural minerals and plant nutrients" but it also has a plethora of bacterial, microbial, and other microscopic life which are essential to healthy plants.

Normally healthy plants do not get diseases. Disease attacks plants that are weak, even though they may look healthy.

As far as Peter's mole problem goes....I once had a cat that was very adept at catching moles. Granted not very humane, but the predator prey relationship between animals is part of nature. It is just one of the things that man's intrusion into formally wild areas has disrupted. The balance between predator and prey is lost when humans kill or drive off the predators and the prey are left to thrive unchecked.

Bard of Ely profile image

Bard of Ely Hub Author 13 months ago

Thanks for your excellent feedback, Teresa!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working